when is it cool to have someone sign a piece of gear?

[Stanz]

Well said, bcmatt!...

Usually, when I see autographed guitars, visions of radio station sleazebags come to mind...

But, my guitar player's G&L broadcaster...with Leo's signature in the neck pocket...Priceless!!

Well, that is different. That is like Picasso signing one of his own pieces of work. I am with you on that, also, autographed guitars smack of some pimped promotion. It was important enough to sign only because someone slipped the artist a few bucks. No thanks.

[mumford]

Warren Haynes signed my 335 right behind the tailpiece at my request. The next day, I saw it and slapped my forehead. For 10 years, I was embarrassed.

Then a couple of months ago, I spent a couple of hours with dish detergent and one of those white scrub pads getting it off. So glad it's gone.

[Structo]

A lot of times denatured alcohol will take off an autograph that was done with a sharpie.