Jelle, I'm curious as to what "doing it right" would include? Replace a lot of components with better quality, higher-rated ones? Gut it and rebuild it more like the original?
I have one of these built 1999. When I got it a year ago, it was stock, apart from a recent cap job and new Ruby 6l6GCs (yuk!). It's a nice amp stock but has more of a modern feel than I suppose I was looking for and TBH a bit piercing and harsh when driven. Not really what I was looking for ... a kinda saggy old tweed.
I'm a great believer in NOS tubes, so I decided that I'd go for 5881's along with a tube rectifier and perhaps 12AYs.
I'd also found reams of info on making mods to get the amp closer to the sound of the original.
Spoke to my amp tech who recommend as a start point, minimal changes to better accommodate the valve changes.
Following was done
R21 changed from 6k8 to 10k
C24 disconnected
Bias adjustment pot installed (Taken off at R41 which was removed).
I'll cut a long story short but ended up with the following tube complement
Rectifier: NOS Tung Sol 5UG4
Power tubes: NOS Tung Sol 5881 (running at 440V and 34ma bias)
V1: NOS GE JAN 6072A
V2: EH 6072A (was pretty good in V! also but the GE edged it)
V3: NOS GE 12AX7
The amp is definitely not as overly bright as it was before with harmonically rich cleans up to about 4 on the vol control. Cranked it is no longer harsh, nice creamy breakup with notes moving into harmonic feedback ... like a fender voiced JTM45 with KT66's! Great touch sensitivity too and nice sag from the rectifier.
Really is a great amp now, would love to change the speakers, probably to Webers, but that is a big investment and pretty happy with it as is.
My only concern is that I'm running those lovely old Tungsols at 10% over max rated voltage, but they seem happy enough.
-make sure all contacts are clean, tight
-put in a bias control
-change any components that need replacing (filters, whatever)
-put in a tube rectifier, possibly one with a relatively higher voltage drop
-change tubes as necessary
-look at the pickup end (adjust resonance by varying C)