New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal
- Milkmansound
 - Posts: 470
 - Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 6:55 pm
 - Contact:
 
New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Any of you guys notice the difference between current production 12AT7's as a reverb driver in a Fender versus the originals? It is night and day - the new tubes do not seem to drive the tank very well in comparison to the old tubes. Its still more than enough reverb - and may even be better in terms of dialing in an appropriate reverb sound... but still!
			
			
									
									
						Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Even among NOS 12AT7s, there were some that made good reverb drivers and others that sucked: different plate styles and wildly inconsistent plate current.
I don't think I've ever seen anybody do a "taste test" on 12AT7s the way everybody likes to do with 12AX7s and output tubes. Maybe some of us should; I'll bet there are reasonable new production 12AT7s out there.
			
			
									
									
						I don't think I've ever seen anybody do a "taste test" on 12AT7s the way everybody likes to do with 12AX7s and output tubes. Maybe some of us should; I'll bet there are reasonable new production 12AT7s out there.
- Milkmansound
 - Posts: 470
 - Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 6:55 pm
 - Contact:
 
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
well, I think I am doing the taste test right now whether I like it or not!
so far JJ's are thumbs down
going to try the Ruby 12AT next
actually, as a general rule, I have been avoiding JJ tubes for every position in my amps except for the rectifier. I started out with all JJ's, and have been slowly disappointed as I have moved down the line starting with the output tubes, then the preamp tubes, and now this
			
			
									
									
						so far JJ's are thumbs down
going to try the Ruby 12AT next
actually, as a general rule, I have been avoiding JJ tubes for every position in my amps except for the rectifier. I started out with all JJ's, and have been slowly disappointed as I have moved down the line starting with the output tubes, then the preamp tubes, and now this
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
There's a lot of variation even from the same manufacturer. Do you have a tube tester? Measuring transconductance and plate current at fixed settings tells a lot.
As to the JJs; I have heard (and unscientifically confirmed) that you have to spring for the ones with the gold plated pins. Not that the gold makes them special, but because JJ first makes the tubes, then tests them, and sends the best ones for gold plating. (Heard this, seems reasonable). I don't know what factors JJ considers in the decision, but the gold pin ones that I tested (12AX7s only, unfortunately) had consistently better-balanced triodes, higher transconductance and higher plate current.
I may order an assortment of ATs and check them out, but I use a Hickok and a Fluke. Someone with an Amplitrex could do a more thorough job. Volunteers?
			
			
									
									
						As to the JJs; I have heard (and unscientifically confirmed) that you have to spring for the ones with the gold plated pins. Not that the gold makes them special, but because JJ first makes the tubes, then tests them, and sends the best ones for gold plating. (Heard this, seems reasonable). I don't know what factors JJ considers in the decision, but the gold pin ones that I tested (12AX7s only, unfortunately) had consistently better-balanced triodes, higher transconductance and higher plate current.
I may order an assortment of ATs and check them out, but I use a Hickok and a Fluke. Someone with an Amplitrex could do a more thorough job. Volunteers?
- Milkmansound
 - Posts: 470
 - Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 6:55 pm
 - Contact:
 
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
I have a B&H tester - but the best test for me seems to be within a single amp and listening for variations
the gold pin theory makes sense, I will try one of those too!
			
			
									
									
						the gold pin theory makes sense, I will try one of those too!
- chief mushroom cloud
 - Posts: 429
 - Joined: Tue Jan 18, 2005 5:42 pm
 - Location: Peenemunde CA
 
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Here's some blather that might answer your question....
http://la-economy.blogspot.com/2012/03/ ... today.html
			
			
									
									http://la-economy.blogspot.com/2012/03/ ... today.html
Don't overthink it. Just drink it.
						Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Thanks for that Chief. It took me a minute to realise it was from Myles; always liked him (even when he was pushing GT).
			
			
									
									
						- Milkmansound
 - Posts: 470
 - Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 6:55 pm
 - Contact:
 
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
that article was depressing
			
			
									
									
						- chief mushroom cloud
 - Posts: 429
 - Joined: Tue Jan 18, 2005 5:42 pm
 - Location: Peenemunde CA
 
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
I wouldn't sweat it...we'll all be dead before all the NOS runs out....who gives a fuck what our kids think...they play that goddamn tek-no and that WASP hippity hop gangsta' rap crapMilkmansound wrote:that article was depressing
I have an IC100 n' a treble booster as a backup plan, anyway.....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKTc4Nk5 ... re=related
and this dood plays an HH combo run into a Marshmallow cab...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N5QYijFfOaQ
					Last edited by chief mushroom cloud on Sat Mar 24, 2012 12:53 am, edited 1 time in total.
									
			
									Don't overthink it. Just drink it.
						- 
				Cliff Schecht
 - Posts: 2629
 - Joined: Wed Dec 30, 2009 7:32 am
 - Location: Austin
 - Contact:
 
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
You might outta watch the racial slurs. We're not the most PC bunch (lord knows I ain't) but I don't think this sort of derogatory slang is welcomed or encouraged.chief mushroom cloud wrote:jigaboo
Cliff Schecht - Circuit P.I.
						Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Hey chief how have you been 
 
Spring hit the Dakota's early this year ,nice!
Mark
			
			
									
									
						Spring hit the Dakota's early this year ,nice!
Mark
- chief mushroom cloud
 - Posts: 429
 - Joined: Tue Jan 18, 2005 5:42 pm
 - Location: Peenemunde CA
 
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
yea, well...the wife er...squaw and I want to take a roadtrip to Crazyhorse monument later this spring.....maybe early May, just in time for some good lightning stormsM Fowler wrote:Hey chief how have you been![]()
Spring hit the Dakota's early this year ,nice!
Mark
would be nice to go now, but got too much work.....sigh
Don't overthink it. Just drink it.
						Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
I love that area of South Dakota we stayed for a week last summer.  
Work on Crazy Horse monument was slow but casino's were thriving.
 
Mark
			
			
									
									
						Work on Crazy Horse monument was slow but casino's were thriving.
Mark
Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Very kewlchief mushroom cloud wrote:and this dood plays an HH combo run into a Marshmallow cab...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N5QYijFfOaQ
He who dies with the most tubes... wins
						Re: New Prod Tubes as reverb driver
Man, I haven't thought about the Cardiac's in years.
I love that band!
			
			
									
									I love that band!
Tom
Don't let that smoke out!
						Don't let that smoke out!