Mr Dumble wrote: 
I do not use amp modeling devices, nor have I ever tried one. My ear is good enough to tell you that all those tones are thin, buzzy and tin can like to me, but the playing is pretty nice.
Hi Mr Dumble,
I am sorry that perhaps I did not make clear enough my question. So please let me try again to avoid misunderstandings:
AFAIR you always introduce/d and present/ed yourself here and elsewhere as someone who has a lot of practical and personal experience with a lot of different musical instruments including many different brands and specimens of guitar amps. And AFAIR you always introduce/d and present/ed yourself here and elsewhere as someone with a pair of extremely well trained ears to hear and to detect even the most subtle differences between the sound and tone of different amps.
If all this should not be the case and just some kind of misunderstanding or prejudice of me, then please correct me.
But if you are the tone expert that you always claim/ed to be AFAIR, then I think you should be able to answer my question. And my question was not if you like the tone of these three clips or if you may perceive them as thin or buzzy or however.
My question was "What kind of guitar amp or modelling device has been used?", and not "Do you like this guitar amp or modelling device which has been used for all these three recordings?"
So please let me ask the same question (at least in my opinion) again, but in a different way to make its content perhaps a bit more clear.
Imagine this e-mail or PM:
Dear Mr Dumble,
I've read on "The Amp Garage" and the "The Gear Page" sites that you are a sound and tone expert and that you have a lot of personal experience with a lot of different guitars and guitar amps. Now I need your advice. I've been booked for a recording session. Here is a list of the recording gear which will be used for the guitar tracks.
And here are three mp3 files. On these three mp3 files you hear precisely the kind of lead guitar tone that the producer wants me to achieve for this recording session. Of course I know that you personally don’t like this kind of guitar tones. But I am a session player and have to achieve the tone the producer asks for. And he did send me these three files in order to make more clear what he wants. And I know what kind of guy this producer is and - believe me - it wouldn't be wise to argue with him regarding this.
So please tell me - based on your vast knowledge about the tone and sound of different guitars in combination with different guitar amps and by using your good and well trained ears - what kind of guitar amplifier you would recommend me to use for this session. I know that you don't have personal experiences with modelling amps, so please recommend just one of the many usual guitar amps you know. Thanks a lot in advance.
Best regards,
Max
I hope that this "example" perhaps makes the content of my question a bit more clear. If not, please just ask.
And IMO someone who has the knowledge, the experience and the good ears you always claim/ed to have should be able to answer such a kind of question.
Mr Dumble wrote:Want me to test you now and watch you fail?
"Tu quoque (pronounced /tjuːˈkwoʊkwɛ/ [1]), or the appeal to hypocrisy, is a kind of logical fallacy. It is a Latin term for "you, too" or "you, also". A tu quoque argument attempts to discredit the opponent's position by asserting his failure to act consistently in accordance with that position; it attempts to show that a criticism or objection applies equally to the person making it. It is considered an ad hominem argument, since it focuses on the party itself, rather than its positions.[2]"
source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque see also:
http://www.fallacyfiles.org/tuquoque.html
All the best and a nice weekend,
Max
