martin manning wrote: ↑Thu Feb 06, 2020 12:26 pm
norburybrook wrote: ↑Thu Feb 06, 2020 10:43 amgetting a faithful recording of the amp can be difficult at times.

I've got recordings that sound great that I can't replicate in the room!!! My 2nd gen sounds like shit sometimes in the room but I've a couple of recordings where it sounds amazing, even with the same setting matched it doesn't sound like that. Drives me mad how sound changes day to day even in the same room.
This is disturbing. If results are generally not repeatable, how can one possibly fine-tune with component selections etc.? At least it says you have to listen over multiple sessions (days) to make a decision to choose one part over another, and any given recording might not be of any value in judging the sound. Why does this happen? is it physical or mental?
that's exactly why I struggle with the whole component thing in general. A good example recently with Alan Darby. I've helped him set up his rig meticulously to the point of obsession. I know exactly how it sounds in his large house. I went to the gig the other night and it sounded completely different in a club on stage, it was suddenly a bit harsh and seemed to have more gain???? nothing had changed except the sound was now in with a band rather than solo. So another guitarist, bass player, drums and keyboards all making the air move in the same space. Some frequencies get boosted some cut, there's various phase things going on, reflections, absorption all going to throw what 'your' particular rig sounds like in that moment. with components all you can do is listen in isolation and make your choice based at that particular moment, whether that means it's the right choice 2 days later in a session or on a gig is a different matter and I suppose you can then come home and change again to remedy this...however you could end up going mad here and changing every week .......therein lies madness though IMHO
Even in the studio , a controlled environment, I have experienced the sound of an amp changing on various days or with various songs. Song key will make a difference sometimes. I know when I Mixing projects sometimes a track will just mix itself almost and another track from the same band with the same instruments will be a struggle as things aren't gelling well frequency wise.
most people listen to their rig in isolation and get a sound they like, I can guarantee on a recording the mix engineer will be cutting most of the low end from a guitar and if you solo'd it it would sound thin and not that pleasing but it will fit in the track nicely. Same thing live, if you have a bass player and keyboards you don't want a lot of low end from a guitar, it takes up too much of the frequency range.
solo guitar is a different matter

you can have any sound you like
have a listen to to Ted Greene's solo album...massive guitar sound , stunning playing too.
M