knob adjustment

Overdrive Special, Steel String Singer, Dumbleland, Odyssey, Winterland, etc. -
Members Only

Moderators: pompeiisneaks, Colossal

User avatar
ayan
Posts: 1340
Joined: Thu Mar 02, 2006 9:04 pm
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Re: knob adjustment

Post by ayan »

dogears wrote:90's amps use PAB in OD mode so the pot taper on the stack is moot. The older 80s amps with the Skyline stack had 30% taper. I had one measured.
That kind of generalization about the 90s amps is really a birdseye view, as per my experience. It's true that people here built HRM amps to "that one" original schematic, which tends to sound not so great in OD without the PAB. That schematic was so widely distributed that there are now statements such as "Dumble intended for the 90s amps to be used that way," as if it were the Gospel. :D But that simply can't quite be the case. For example, I tried another 90s amp here in L.A., which a couple of other locals (from TGP) have tried as well, that sounded very different from at least my build of the 90s circuit -- which, of course, is the same one that everyone else used when building their clones as well, with the low gain input to the OD, etc. This other amp had a lot more gain on tap and didn't seem to be bass heavy at high gain settings and without the PAB on. So the tone stack thing may not be a moot point if one is willing to consider the possibility that there exist other schematics of 90s amps, which of course has to be the case.

[ Furthermore, if RF's amp is a HRM -- the million dollar question! -- then his amp is definitely different; it sounds really good in OD without the PAB. RF tap dances on his pedalboard and uses all four possible combinations of channels and PAB, and the sound of the amp is always "the" RF tone. :) ]

As for The 80s amps that I have seen in person, which were later converted to Skyliner by Dumble, they used Alpha pots for the treble (250KB) and the Bass (500KA) slots. Easy to check with the pictures of 124 I took and posted, for instance, as I have some very detailed close ups of the backs of the pots. There is one amp I have pictures of, nevertheless, which I've never seen in person, that was built as a Skyliner from the get go and that has what looks to be either Alpah pots or C TS with shiny backs all the way around, but there is not enough detail in the pictures to be sure. Those may as well be 30% taper all around, for all I know.

Needless to say, I am not suggesting the one 80s amp that someone else measured and told you about didn't have a 500KA 30% taper pot on the bass slot. I am stating that is unlike what I've seen myself, and since I've seen a few amps, those two pieces of information -- mine and your contact's -- make any generalization invalid out right of the bat.

If anyone has a chance to measure pot tapers of more amps it would be really cool, however, since that necessiates unsoldering one lug on all pots except the "middle," I wouldn't expecte for there to be many volunteer owners.

Cheers,

Gil
dogears
Posts: 1902
Joined: Wed Feb 01, 2006 1:29 pm

Re: knob adjustment

Post by dogears »

Hi Gil,

#224 that Bob-I and I both played a few weeks ago was exactly like my 90s amp in feel and gain structure. It probably has the same or similar low gain network. Fwiw, my 90s gets a very nice non PAB tone at jam levels. Really sweet in fact. I've been digging it a lot.

I do agree that there are tons of alternate possibilities on other 90s Dumbles. I have messed with the low gain network at great length. We discussed this before on the phone. The knee frequency of the 47pf over 470k versus alternates.....

Anywho.... I was just saying that the 80s voice with .01 midcap, seems to like the mid control set fairly high.
User avatar
ayan
Posts: 1340
Joined: Thu Mar 02, 2006 9:04 pm
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Re: knob adjustment

Post by ayan »

dogears wrote:Hi Gil,

Anywho.... I was just saying that the 80s voice with .01 midcap, seems to like the mid control set fairly high.
Agreed, otherwise the sound can be boomy. The other thing I am not sure I understand is why, although the Skyliner is basically bassier than the older EQ, the bass knob seems to want to be turned up. It is counter intuitive, but it simply yields a better tone that way. Experienced this on my amp as well as Chris's.

I have to confess I've come to "broaden" my taste about the Skyliner EQ. Several months ago I changed one of my two (I need more!) amps from early 80s to Skyliner, and of course at first I felt the EQ wasn't right, etc., etc., which had been my impression before when I'd toyed with that circuit back in 1999. But, the Tele felt great with the Skyliner EQ, and so I kept that amp that way.

After gigging with it a few times, using both a 335 and a Tele, I have come to simply love the way the amp sounds. It's not as "easy to play" as the early 80s at low volumes, but when played loud Skyliner just kills. Even soloing on the clean channel without the PAB seems to be a good choice. I have not deared to use it with the Strat, let alone at a gig, and to me that's by far the weakest combination. Interestingly, I love the way the Sky sounds in OD w/o the PAB.

Bottom line, one simply can't go by where the knobs are pointing on a real Dumble, as there are many combiantions of pots that could be used on each amp.

Gil
dogears
Posts: 1902
Joined: Wed Feb 01, 2006 1:29 pm

Re: knob adjustment

Post by dogears »

Hey! I also said that thing about the bass pot!!! I set both up around 2 oclock. Any less and it loses magic...... Welcome to the dogears kennel. Woof!
ayan wrote:
dogears wrote:Hi Gil,

Anywho.... I was just saying that the 80s voice with .01 midcap, seems to like the mid control set fairly high.
Agreed, otherwise the sound can be boomy. The other thing I am not sure I understand is why, although the Skyliner is basically bassier than the older EQ, the bass knob seems to want to be turned up. It is counter intuitive, but it simply yields a better tone that way. Experienced this on my amp as well as Chris's.

I have to confess I've come to "broaden" my taste about the Skyliner EQ. Several months ago I changed one of my two (I need more!) amps from early 80s to Skyliner, and of course at first I felt the EQ wasn't right, etc., etc., which had been my impression before when I'd toyed with that circuit back in 1999. But, the Tele felt great with the Skyliner EQ, and so I kept that amp that way.

After gigging with it a few times, using both a 335 and a Tele, I have come to simply love the way the amp sounds. It's not as "easy to play" as the early 80s at low volumes, but when played loud Skyliner just kills. Even soloing on the clean channel without the PAB seems to be a good choice. I have not deared to use it with the Strat, let alone at a gig, and to me that's by far the weakest combination. Interestingly, I love the way the Sky sounds in OD w/o the PAB.

Bottom line, one simply can't go by where the knobs are pointing on a real Dumble, as there are many combiantions of pots that could be used on each amp.

Gil
User avatar
ayan
Posts: 1340
Joined: Thu Mar 02, 2006 9:04 pm
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Re: knob adjustment

Post by ayan »

dogears wrote:Hey! I also said that thing about the bass pot!!! I set both up around 2 oclock. Any less and it loses magic...... Welcome to the dogears kennel. Woof!
I would never question your good taste for tone.... :P

Gil
Post Reply